A woman sought our help because she hadn’t received Ontario Disability Support Program (ODSP) payments or drug benefits from August 2020 to October 2021. RESULT: After our intervention, the manager reviewing the file discovered the woman’s caseworker had made a mistake in calculating her benefits. …
Body
A woman sought our help because she hadn’t received Ontario Disability Support Program (ODSP) payments or drug benefits from August 2020 to October 2021.
/en/our-work/case-stories/pricey-blunder
Long-distance resolution
A woman who had been living outside of Canada for 15 years sought our help in obtaining more than $25,000 in child support through the Family Responsibility Office (FRO). When she left Ontario, she had asked the FRO to hold the payments for her as they accumulated, as it was easier for her to cash …
Body
A woman who had been living outside of Canada for 15 years sought our help in obtaining more than $25,000 in child support through the Family Responsibility Office (FRO).
An international student at a college of applied arts and technology requested a tuition refund when he decided to leave his program and return home to India. The college told him he had missed its deadline to withdraw and receive a refund. He asked our Office for help, saying the financial …
Body
An international student at a college of applied arts and technology requested a tuition refund when he decided to leave his program and return home to India.
/en/our-work/case-stories/helpful-information
Fair trade
A student sought our help after his college told him he would have to retake a trade course he had already effectively completed, which would delay his graduation and the full-time employment he had arranged. His college had given him under 48 hours to accept an opportunity to complete additional …
Body
A student sought our help after his college told him he would have to retake a trade course he had already effectively completed, which would delay his graduation and the full-time employment he had arranged.
/en/our-work/case-stories/fair-trade
Course correction
A group of 50 students at a university reached out to our Office for help after they all failed the same course. The students, most of whom were international students, raised concerns about the instruction, grades and feedback they received from the university, and the financial consequences of …
Body
A group of 50 students at a university reached out to our Office for help after they all failed the same course.
/en/our-work/case-stories/course-correction
More fair, less taxing
A woman who could not pay her property taxes due to financial hardship sought our help after her municipality refused her request to cancel her debt. Instead, it took steps to sell her property. Her complaint raised several questions of fairness, including whether the municipality gave her adequate …
Body
A woman who could not pay her property taxes due to financial hardship sought our help after her municipality refused her request to cancel her debt.
/en/our-work/case-stories/more-fair-less-taxing
In the zone
A homeowner reached out to us when the land around her home was rezoned from agricultural to industrial. She was concerned that her municipality hadn’t engaged with residents before making the decision, and that proper environmental assessments were not done. RESULT: We reached out to municipal …
Body
A homeowner reached out to us when the land around her home was rezoned from agricultural to industrial.
/en/our-work/case-stories/zone
Municipal mine-field
We were contacted by the leaseholder of Crown land that included ski trails and a drainage system that had previously been installed by his municipality. He told us these were contrary to his lease agreement with the Ministry of Mines, which required all activities on the property to be related to …
Body
We were contacted by the leaseholder of Crown land that included ski trails and a drainage system that had previously been installed by his municipality.
/en/our-work/case-stories/municipal-mine-field
Stair-struck
A business owner complained to us after his municipality informed him that a set of stairs on the back of his building encroached on municipal property. He told us his family had operated a business in the building for 40 years before buying the land from the city in 2004 and had never been told …
Body
A business owner complained to us after his municipality informed him that a set of stairs on the back of his building encroached on municipal property.
/en/our-work/case-stories/stair-struck
Report as required
We received complaints from two inmates at the same facility, alleging they had been sexually assaulted. One inmate complained that they were sexually assaulted by another inmate, and the other complained that they were sexually assaulted by staff. When we inquired with facility staff, we found …
Body
We received complaints from two inmates at the same facility, alleging they had been sexually assaulted.
/en/our-work/case-stories/report-required
Privacy protections
We received complaints from a group of 10 inmates, all women, that they were strip searched by correctional officers in their unit, in view of one another. We flagged this case to senior staff at the facility. RESULT: After our intervention, the facility purchased privacy screens to prevent similar …
Body
We received complaints from a group of 10 inmates, all women, that they were strip searched by correctional officers in their unit, in view of one another.
/en/our-work/case-stories/privacy-protections
Mistaken identity
A transgender inmate contacted our Office after she was involved in an altercation with correctional officers. When we made inquiries, we learned that the facility’s computer system had not been updated with the correct information regarding the inmate’s gender identity, even though she had …
Body
A transgender inmate contacted our Office after she was involved in an altercation with correctional officers.
/en/our-work/case-stories/mistaken-identity
2023-2024 Annual Report
O N TA R I O O N TA R I O ’ S WAT C H D O G Annual Report 2023-2024 Office of the Ombudsman of Ontario O N We T areAdedicated R Ito being O an effective agent of positive change for the people of Ontario. We do this by standing for the rights and well-being of Ontarians, ensuring their voices are …
Body
Ombudsman's Message - Focusing on rights – and the future: It is an honour to present my ninth Annual Report as Ombudsman as this Office prepares to mark its 49th anniversary. The time is ripe for both reflection and forward thinking – and this report, fittingly, does both.
Submission regarding Proposed Policy Directive Updates for Children's Aid Societies
Submission to the Ministry of Children, Community and Social Services regarding Proposed Policy Directive Updates to Clarify Data Collection and Reporting Requirements for Children's Aid Societies Respecting the New Youth Leaving Care Policy and “Ready, Set, Go” Program Paul Dubé Ombudsman of …
Body
The Ministry of Children, Community and Social Services has requested comments on a regulatory proposal related to amendments to Policy Directive: CW 003-23 — Preparing Youth for Successful Transition from the Care of Children’s Aid Societies.
Saugeen Mobility and Regional Transit (SMART) - September 23, 2024
Ombudsman Report Investigation into a complaint about a meeting held by the Board of Directors for Saugeen Mobility and Regional Transit Paul Dubé Ombudsman of Ontario September 2024 Complaint 1 My Office received a complaint that the Board of Directors for Saugeen Mobility and Regional Transit …
Body
The Ombudsman received a complaint that the Board of Directors for Saugeen Mobility and Regional Transit (SMART) does not hold meetings that are open to the public. The Ombudsman found that SMART is a shared local board of 10 member municipalities that is subject to the open meeting rules in the Municipal Act, 2001.
Towns of Grimsby and Lincoln and Township of West Lincoln - September 18, 2024
Ombudsman Report Investigation into complaints about a closed meeting held by the Town of Grimsby, the Town of Lincoln, and the Township of West Lincoln Paul Dubé Ombudsman of Ontario September 2024 Complaint 1 My Office received complaints that council members from the Town of Grimsby, the Town of …
Body
The Ombudsman received complaints that a joint meeting held by the councils for the Town of Grimsby, the Town of Lincoln and the Township of West Lincoln did not adhere to the open meeting rules. The Ombudsman found that the first part of the closed session discussion fit within the closed meeting exception for education or training. However, small-group discussions that occurred during the second part of the closed session did not fit within any of the exceptions.
Ombudsman Report Investigation into a complaint about a meeting of council for the Town of Halton Hills on August 28, 2023 Paul Dubé Ombudsman of Ontario August 2024 Complaint 1 My Office received a complaint about a meeting of council for the Town of Halton Hills (the “Town”) on August 28, 2023. …
Body
The Ombudsman received a complaint regarding a meeting of council for the Town of Halton Hills held on August 28, 2023. The complaint alleged that council’s closed session discussion of recent provincial policy announcements about municipalities did not fit within the closed meeting exceptions in the Municipal Act, 2001. The complaint also alleged that council did not pass a resolution stating that this matter would be discussed in closed session.
The Ombudsman found that the discussion did not fit within any exceptions to the open meeting rules, and that council failed to include a general description of this topic in its resolution to proceed into closed session. Council accordingly contravened the Municipal Act, 2001 on August 28, 2023. The Ombudsman also noted that council’s minutes incorrectly suggested that council had included this topic of discussion in its resolution when it had not.
Ombudsman Report Investigation into meetings held by council for the Township of Jocelyn on January 10 and 13, February 7, April 4, and October 10, 2023 Paul Dubé Ombudsman of Ontario September 2024 Complaint 1 My Office received three complaints that council for the Township of Jocelyn (the …
Body
The Ombudsman investigated closed meetings held by council for the Township of Jocelyn on January 10 and 13, February 7, April 4, and October 10, 2023 and found that the discussions at each of these meetings fit within various closed meeting exceptions in the Municipal Act, 2001. However, the Ombudsman also found that the Township contravened the Act at its October 10 meeting by failing to pass a resolution to enter into closed session, failing to take closed meeting minutes, and by improperly closing the beginning of the meeting to the public. Although no illegal votes occurred at the meetings, the Ombudsman nevertheless recommended as a best practice that council clearly identify any specific directions given in closed session, formally vote on them, and record that vote in the closed meeting minutes.
Submission regarding Bill 188, Supporting Children's Futures Act, 2024
Submission to the Standing Committee on Social Policy regarding Bill 188, Supporting Children's Futures Act, 2024 Paul Dubé Ombudsman of Ontario May 2024 Overview The Standing Committee on Social Policy is currently considering Bill 188, An Act to amend the Child, Youth and Family Services Act, …
Body
The Standing Committee on Social Policy is currently considering Bill 188, An Act to amend the Child, Youth and Family Services Act, 2017 and various other Acts, also known as the Supporting Children’s Futures Act, 2024.
Ombudsman Report Investigation into complaints about a meeting held by the Township of Lanark Highlands’ Committee of the Whole on June 27, 2023 Paul Dubé Ombudsman of Ontario August 2024 Overview 1 My Office received two complaints that the Committee of the Whole for the Township of Lanark …
Body
The Ombudsman reviewed a complaint that the Committee of the Whole for the Township of Lanark Highlands contravened the open meeting rules on June 27, 2023 when it discussed a management letter regarding draft financial statements with an auditor during a closed session.
The Ombudsman found that the discussion about the management letter fit within the exception for security of the property of the municipality because the information discussed related to an ongoing threat to the security of the municipality’s property. However, the Ombudsman found that the Township contravened the requirements of section 239(7) of the Municipal Act, 2001 on June 27, 2023 by failing to keep an adequate record of what was discussed in camera. As a best practice, the Ombudsman recommended that the Township make audio or video recordings of its closed sessions.